I was reading another blog earlier today. I felt a kinship with the author – she was writing about her struggles to eat clean and exercise and lead a disciplined life. I was thoroughly enjoying her writing.

Until I saw her stats.

I felt cheated. Why? Because, going by her stats, she wasn’t “struggling” (in my book) – she was tall and slim with a ridiculously low fat body %. She was clocking 5km runs all the time and loving it. I couldn’t see anywhere on her blog that she had been otherwise at any stage.

And I felt cheated because, in my mind, she’s perfect and I’m here struggling. I started feeling angry for some reason.

I had to stop and think. What gives me the right to judge who’s struggling and who’s not? Why the jealousy? Why the competitive streak?

Everyone starts from a different point and what is intolerable to one person is perfection to another. I remember when I started Weight Watchers 2 years ago or so. There was another girl starting the same night. We did our first weigh in and our assessment and my starting weight ended up being her goal weight. The weight that had made me feel like a heifer (and had prompted a doctor of all people to ask “When are you due?”) was a perfect weight for her.

Why do we compare ourselves to other people? I know that the winner of ANTM, Whitney Thompson, has said she’s a size 10-12 and I’ve read so many comments on blogs and forums about how X commenter is a size 10 and Whitney’s definitely bigger than her or smaller or whatnot. Every body carries weight differently. If you’re pear shaped (like me), you can look tiny on top but have to go up 2 sizes for your pants (thanks childbearing hips, love you too!) but if you’re more apple shaped, you often have amazing legs but have to go up a size for your tops. So technically, you can weigh the same but look completely different.

So the blogger who is perfect by my standards? She has her own struggles and I can’t judge her for that. I’m sure once I post my stats, someone else reading this will think “I’d love to have those stats – what a cow to complain!”.

Weight and body image is such a personal struggle.


4 thoughts on “Perception

  1. Hmm yes how very true.

    But have you also thought about how inaccurate our persceptions of our own bodies are? I mean when I was (a lot) lighter I always used to think how overweight I am and how I need to go on a diet. Of course, now looking back I WISH I was as “overweight” as I used to be. If only I knew then…

    New blogger at:

  2. Oh, completely true as well. Body image is such a weird thing. I always thought of myself as the heavy one at school and I was a LOT lighter than I am now.

  3. It is a good reminder, though, for those of us who are lucky enough to have reasonable metabolisms and are just trying to maintain their weight rather than lose. I often whine about “struggles” when really, I don’t have much to whine about. If I were someone just starting out and trying to reach a very difficult goal, I’d want to slap me sometimes. “Oh, poor Crabby, she can’t eat all the cupcakes she wants!”

    It’s like me listening to cute twenty five year olds complaining about how “old” they’re looking.

  4. Crabby, that’s so true. It’s difficult to see it sometimes and put things into perspective.
    Although I can never eat all the cupcakes I want!
    Thanks for stopping by 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s